Pie-in-a-Box: Crave Brothers Farmstead Classics Chocolate Mascarpone Pie Kit

Chocolate marscapone pie kit, Crave Brothers

Super-easy, no-bake chocolate mascarpone pie kit.

Not a baker? No worries because Wisconsin cheese experts, Crave Brothers Farmstead Cheese Company, will send you everything you need to make a rich, creamy Chocolate Mascarpone Pie. And you don’t even have to turn on your oven!

When we heard about Crave Brother’s pie kit, we just had to try it. The kit arrived via UPS overnight in a large cardboard box with the words “refrigerate immediately” on it. Since it was 25 degrees out, we didn’t have to worry too much about refrigerating the box. It was plenty cold.

shipping carton pie kit

Crave Brothers Chocolate Mascarpone pie kit comes shipped in a big cardboard box.

Inside the box there was a large plastic insulated sack and two frozen cool packs to keep the kit cool during transport. In the shipping box was a 12-ounce bag of Hershey’s Dark Chocolate Chips, a chocolate Oreo cookie crust, and 16 ounces of Crave Brothers Farmstead Classics Mascarpone Cheese. There was also a recipe for making the pie (and the crust from actual chocolate wafer crumbs). The only thing I needed to add was a couple of tablespoons of Kahlua or Amaretto.

Stirring chocolate mascarpone pie in bowl

The pie filling involves just mixing melted chocolate, mascarpone cheese, and liqueur together. Easy!

If you order the pie kit, give the mascarpone some time to come to room temperature. I was too excited to wait and, after melting half the bag of chocolate chips, tried to mix the warm chocolate and coldish mascarpone. Not a good combination. The stiffness of the mascarpone made the blending tough going and caused some of my melted chocolate to unmelt, leaving little bits of chocolate throughout the mixture. I eventually resorted to using my mixer, which made it a bit easier. Then I added two tablespoons of Amaretto and stirred it in.

I put the filling into the provided Oreo cookie crumb pie shell, popped it in the refrigerator for an hour, and topped it with whipped cream. Totally easy; super quick.

mascarpone pie with wooden spoon in bowl

Because I didn’t let my mascarpone come to room temperature like the recipe said, my melted chocolate chips unmelted and put little bits of chocolate into the mixture.

And how’d it taste? Creamy, rich, chocolately with the mascarpone providing a lovely accent that softened the sweet chocolate. My guests loved it and certainly thought I’d labored much longer than the few minutes it took to put this pie together.

Crave Brothers Farmstead Classics Mascarpone pie slice

With this easy-does-it pie kit you can make a beautiful and delicious pie in no time.

Crave Brothers Mascarpone Pie Kit is $23.99. The Gift Box has to be received within two days of shipping to keep the cheese safe.The kit is shipped from Wisconsin, so, If you lives nearby, you can pay ground and receive it in a day. If it is further away, you’ll have to pay for 2nd day air or, if you need it more quickly, have it shipped overnight.

If you’d rather gather your own ingredients and not use Crave Brothers super-convenient pie kit, you can use their recipe instead.

Want to know more about Crave Brothers Farmstead Cheese? Check out our review.

Interested in other recipes featuring creamy mascarpone cheese? Take a taste of these:

Lemon Mascarpone Tarts

Pumpkin Agnolotti

Mascarpone & Layered Beets with Candied Walnuts




Bobbie Hasselbring, RFT Editor

RFT co-founder Bobbie Hasselbring has been a travel junkie her entire life. An award-winning writer and editor for more than 25 years and author of the regional food-travel bestsellers, The Chocolate Lover’s Guide to the Pacific Northwest and The Chocolate Lover’s Guide Cookbook, Bobbie is editor-in-chief at

2 thoughts on “Pie-in-a-Box: Crave Brothers Farmstead Classics Chocolate Mascarpone Pie Kit

Comments are closed.