Olympia – Jan/Feb 2018
Seaside – Jan/Feb/March 2018

Tuscan Wines Shine…in Maine

wine bottleAmong my favorite Italian expressions is, “Anni e bicchieri di vino no si contano mai,” or “Years and glasses of wine should never be counted.” Here at Enoteca Athena in Brunswick, Maine, I am eager to begin a relaxed, uncounted evening of sipping and savoring the flavors of Tuscany’s Poggio Alloro winery and farm.


Italian olives pair perfectly with Italian wines.

olive oil

Part of the reason Italian food is so terrific, is the ingredients are local and fresh.

Enoteca Athena is bustling and convivial with a flurry of arrivals and warm greetings. I see my old friend, Paul Turina, the Italian wine dealer who arranged this evening. Living in Italy agrees with him.

The county-Italian enoteca is informal and relaxed. A wooden ladder hangs overhead draped in dried herbs and twinkly mason-jar lights. A sliding barn door and bright Italian pottery lend a rustic feel, and a wreath of chili peppers hints at the flavorful evening to come.

Sip and Savor

wine maker

It was lovely seeing my old friend and Italian wine dealer, Paul Turina.

Sarah Fiorini is here representing Poggio Alloro, her family’s 250-acre winery, farm and agriturismo in San Gimignano. Tonight, we will enjoy their lush organic wines, olive oil, and honey.

I visited the Poggio Alloro several years ago, and it is wonderful to see Sarah again. Her relaxed, friendly manner makes us all feel like family. Our first lesson is toasting — “Salute!” with Italian gusto and vigor, followed by “Buon appetito!”

We begin the evening with a generous pour of light, dry Toscana Bianco, whose flavor evokes citrus, honey, apricots and Tuscan flowers.

white wine

Toscana Bianco is a light, dry wine with flavors of citrus, honey, apricots and Tuscan flowers.

La Prima

Our first course is whipped salt cod (baccalà) with olive oil and capers. Maine shrimp are similarly pureed with olive oil, and flavored with red saffron threads — unctuous and light. Rustic bread from Standard is perfect for tasting the spreads and for sampling the farm’s extra-virgin olive oil. In fact, the whole evening is steeped in in Poggio Alloro’s extra virgin olive oil—which almost steals the show.


Our second wine is a pink-tinged Vernaccia, from the Italian vernaculo, or indigenous. This beautiful wine hints at golden apple, almonds and vanilla. An arugula salad with fennel, prosciutto, walnuts and topped with crispy bits of (believe it or not) chicken skin, is a smash with the delicate, minerally wine—definitely a great pairing.


Wine grapes are as ubiquitous as they are beautiful in Tuscany.

Rosso di Toscano

Our third taste is ruby-colored Rosso di Toscano, an everyday wine that, according to Sarah, improves the heart and circulation. I can feel my heart beating more efficiently already. People have been drinking this unpretentious red since 1276, “When Dante wrote the La Divina Commedia,” Sarah says. “Wow, you know?” She winks at us.

If there is a groove, we’re now all in it.

Chef O’Brien

Our third course is my idea of a perfect light supper, una cena leggera, very thin cannelloni pasta stuffed with meat and spicy fennel flavor in a delicate tomato sauce, topped with almost weightless Bechamel. Chef O’Brien really knows his way around pasta.

chef making pasta

Chef rolls out fresh pasta.

It’s a tough act serving 40 people seated family-style in a small room, and Enoteca Athena is doing the best they can. Since it’s easily the coldest night of the year, some of the courses cool down a bit too quickly, but the staff valiantly runs food and wine from kitchen to guests. Kudos to chef and staff for facing down the icy end of a tough Maine winter. Well done.


Convivo red wine

Garnet red Convivo, my favorite Poggio Alloro wine, is perfect for the meat course..

The meat course is served with my favorite Poggio Alloro wine, Convivio. I have loved this wine since I visited the winery all those years ago. The garnet colored red has flavors of cherry, raspberry and hints of cinnamon. The crowd discusses the wine’s “nose,” and somebody yells out, “Tobacco!” Right again. The wine is robust, warm and velvety on this frigid Maine evening. I have seconds — maybe thirds. But nobody’s counting.

Grilling outdoors in sub-zero weather is daunting, and brave Chef O’Brien is bundled up like Nanook. The last meat course is a challenge. Guests murmur, “At least it will be rare.” It is. The beef arrives piled high and on-the-bone, served on heavy white platters — Flintstonian and dramatic.

Siamo alla Frutta

Italians express the end of the evening as, “siamo alla frutta,” at the fruit. Traditional vin santo and cantucci arrive, another wow for Poggio Alloro. Made from almost-dry grapes, the amber holy wine is aged six years. With has hints of caramel, nuts and honey, vin santo is served with not-so-sweet cantucci biscotti for dipping in the sweet wine. Perfect.


Italian fruits and veggies like these gorgeous canned tomatoes are usually grown organically on small farms.

I am starting to feel abbiocco, the lovely drowsiness that follows a satisfying meal. Thank you Poggio Alloro, Paul Turina, Enoteca Athena and Chef O’Brien — sono pieno come un uovo — I am full as an egg. – Story and photos by Elizabeth “Libby” Margolis-Pineo, RFT East Coast Editor

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Elizabeth Margolis-Pineo, East Coast Editor

Elizabeth “Libby” Margolis-Pineo knows her way around a tasting menu. She’s attended countless wine, sake, and beer tastings and she loves all things brunchy and boozy. She’smashed ripe Tuscan figs into her mouth straight from the tree, ordered Poutine well past midnight in Montreal, and will eat the skin of just about any roasted animal, especially pig. In addition to being a food and travel writer, Libby imports a line of cozy and stylish shawls from Italy – “Italian Warmth for Maine Winters." She is also founder and editor of which she created to showcase her published work and ongoing adventures. Libby is delighted to be East Coast Editor of