Door County, Wisconsin offers such a wide array of experiences, our Eco-Friendly Food, Travel & Adventure Editor, Jimmy McDonough, needed two articles to describe what awaits travelers to this memorable area. Here in part one, Jimmy covers the “finer” side of art, food, and drink. In Part 2, we learn about the “wilder” adventurous side of Door County, Wisconsin.

Save this article to Pinterest about the finer side of Door County, WI to help you plan your trip. Photos by Jimmy McDonough. Graphic by Real Food Traveler.
A dagger of land forms the Door Peninsula – separating Lake Michigan from Green Bay, Wisconsin. Along its 80-mile length, an idyllic blend of farms, orchards, and a smattering of villages and farmhouses offers a beautiful landscape to explore. Let’s get to know these places and some of the stories behind the makers and creatives of Door County to plan your visit to this magical place!
Dining Door County
A unique microclimate is formed by the large bodies of water on either side of the Door peninsula, creating the perfect conditions for industrious and hardy souls to plant fruiting trees, vineyards, pastures, and a dense array of makers and creatives. Every moment touring the area is filled with scenic pastures, forests, iconic silos and barns. Sprinkled with waterside villages, galleries, roadside farm stands and many other surprises to enjoy at a leisurely pace in the off-season. Here are a few standouts on the Door County culinary scene.
The village of Sister Bay offers a larger array of shops, food options, and unique sights (such as the local celebrity goats in this article). Overlooking the main street at the top of a hill, Sister Bay Bowl and Supper Club has been a locals’ favorite spot for generations. Owned by the same family for decades (who once lived in what is now the dining room) the place has evolved over the years to include a classic bowling alley. The wood-paneled dive bar offers local craft brews on draft, classic and creative cocktails (an Old-Fashioned made with maple bitters anyone?) and cheap canned beers. Even on a Monday night in the quiet season, it was hopping with locals seeking their perch fish fillet dinner special. I opted for the locally harvested whitefish dinner, broasted to perfection. Fun fact – some staff have worked at the restaurant long before the current generation of owners was born!
Wild Tomato, another Sister Bay eatery, serves up the perfect pizza crust (crispy outside, soft and pillowy inside) topped by traditional (Naples-style pizza Margherita anyone?) to unique creative toppings. Each week, a special combination is available with a portion of the proceeds from each pie sold being donated to local charity. On my visit, the special combination included duck confit/pork belly/butternut squash and a white sauce – unexpected and delicious. Paired with a salad, served with locally produced goat cheese, it was a hearty lunch before hitting the trails for the afternoon.
Sturgeon Bay is a mildly industrial small city with a terrific Maritime Museum and a charming historic core. When passing through on your way up the peninsula, stop by Scaturo’s (open early) and pick up a bag full of delicious pastries – perhaps a Coffee Ring (blueberry, cherry, and classic were on display for my visit) or a Kringle (the Chocolate Éclair kringle was hard to pass up!). Their tart/not overly sweet Door County cherry pie is the best I’ve ever had. Stop by for breakfast or lunch, or to take fully-prepped meals, packaged to take with you and pop in the oven of your vacation cottage – including some vegetarian options. Robert Scaturo, a transplanted Jersey boy 30 years ago, fell for the friendly and generous community; with his wife JoAnne, they built their comfy Scaturo’s into a beloved community pillar. During the pandemic, they served this community by cooking up low-cost, hearty, family-style takeaway meals to ensure no one went hungry.
Thyme is a casual, yet stylish restaurant with a menu that offers iconic Wisconsin faves like cheese curds and smoked whitefish dip (harvested locally) with cherry compote (grown locally), vegetarian and vegan options, and adventurous dishes inspired by global cuisines. The chef is committed to using locally grown/harvested food products whenever possible. For an elevated, snooty-free dining experience, Thyme is a lovely option.

Locally raised white fish and locally grown cherries are parts of the iconic food scene in Door County.
Hungry for more? Get recipes using Door County cherries.
Savoring the Bounty of Door County WI
Crafting prepared foods and beverages from the bounty of the land is a natural “next step” for food and beverage producers along the Door peninsula.
Anchored Roots Vineyard & Winery
Stop by this lovely start-up winery owned by husband-and-wife team Amy and Eric Gale for an array of nicely crafted wines made from Washington state grapes. Why Washington grapes? Eric learned the art and science of winemaking while attending viticulture school in Washington state and believes the grapes are second to none. Now he is intent on creating wholly unique wines that are both delicious and sustainable in Wisconsin, using IPM practices (Integrated Pest Management) to minimize the use of chemicals. He has selected unique new cold-hardy varietal vines to be planted on the property to provide grapes that express the terroir of Door County – Eric’s future wines will merit a return visit.

Winemaker Eric Gale stirs fermenting grapes used to make the wine at Anchored Roots Vineyard & Winery.
When visiting Anchored Roots, be sure to drop by nearby Horseshoe Bay Farms for a fascinating glimpse at Door County’s preserved agriculture history and other seasonal surprises such as gardens, Stickwork art display, and special events.

Horseshoe Bay Farms
Hungry for more? Itinerary for three perfect days in Door Country.
Island Orchard Cider
Passion and knowledge pour out of cidermaker Bob Purman, and it shows in every delicious sip of his product. Made with rare varietal apples grown in his own orchards of over 4,000 trees, his ciders take inspiration from the drier ciders of Brittany and Normandy in France, with a unique Door County twist like lavender and cherry infused options. Island Orchard’s sustainable practices, such as organic growing practices, using geothermal heating/cooling, and using cider by-product for a line of vinegars, are noteworthy.

A tasting at Island Orchard Cidery may include fresh apple varietals used in the final product.
Seaquist Orchards
Family run for generations, this Door County staple has grown over the years from a simple apple orchard to a provider of solid, year-round jobs for a staff making over 100 products with local ingredients. Fresh apples and other fruits and seasonal vegetables are now supplemented with jarred items, ciders, a bakery, and a wide array of sauces and dry ingredients for home cooking.
Hungry for more? Learn about the iconic Al Johnson’s Restaurant.
Celebrating Door County Creators
Approximately 100 galleries can be found among the pastoral byways of Door County – a surprising count given that only 30,000 people populate the entire peninsula. I visited a trio that, like many other businesses in Door County, are passion projects of husband-and-wife teams.
Burnt Bluff Stone and Glass
When one of their little daughters asked, “Is it safe to play outside?”, Kari and Ryan Dayton knew it was time to make a change when their answer was “No”. From the hectic urban life of central Denver, they wanted to raise their two daughters in a safer, calmer, and closer-to-nature community. With roots in Wisconsin, Ryan knew Door County was the perfect place, and with Kari opened their glass blowing and gift business. With lots of practice, Ryan continually hones his craft, experimenting with new techniques and creating new designs each season. For Christmas last year, it was trees; for this holiday season it will be snowmen (judging from his prototype, they will be adorable!). Now Kari and Ryan’s little girls wander carefree on their land chasing chickens and “helping” mommy and daddy run the business.
TIP: Be sure to stop by Ray’s Cherry Hut next door for some good roadside tacos, hot dogs, local cider and craft beers and a great outdoor dining area. The indoors is an eclectic mix of fun artifacts you might find in your Dad’s garage or man-cave.

Stop and enjoy glassblowing demos at Burnt Bluff followed by a bite to eat at Ray’s Cherry Hut.
Woodwalk Gallery
Housed in an ancient dairy barn, with light and air filtering through the open slats, this gallery was recently acquired by Matt and Joslyn Villalpando. Joslyn encountered the gallery years ago and fell in love, vowing to return and own it one day. Her wish finally came true and with Matt and children, relocated from the big city to live their best lives in Door County. Their gallery displays a wide array of art from artists near and far. Their beautiful property includes spaces for outdoor events – weddings are especially popular in the wildflower meadow with a sunflower maze and conifer backdrop. Embedded in the community, they offer an array of events and activities from live music to dinners in the field (well, on the outside terrace overlooking the fields!).

Woodwalk Gallery is spectacular from any angle.
Plum Bottom Gallery
A potter and ceramicist by trade, Chad Luberger, together with his wife Angela Olsen Luberger, an accomplished jewelry maker, opened their original gallery in a charming cottage set off the main road amid fields and pastures. The same cottage where Chad honed his pottery craft in one room, and eventually was displaced by the gallery. Since those humble beginnings, demand for beautiful objects from tourists and locals alike has enabled them to open two more galleries in other Door County villages. They invite both local and national artists to show their work, ranging from paintings, sculptures, jewelry, to home and garden décor. A common theme to much of the art is a love for nature – especially the natural world of Door County.

The original Plum Bottom Gallery, a charming cottage off the beaten path, surrounded by pastures.
Travel tips for Door County, WI
The Destination Door County website offers great tips for trip planning.
Eagle Harbor Inn makes a great homebase while in Door County. Learn more about it in our Part 2 article on Door County, coming up.
Flights into nearby Appleton and Green Bay airports are readily available; a two-hour, scenic drive brings you to the area of the peninsula described in this article. A car is really a must have to tour around, especially in the off-season (late Fall through spring thaw); seasonal trolley tours may be helpful (and fun!) for local hops and to reduce traffic.
You can use this Real Food Traveler Hotels.com or Expedia.com affiliate links to make your reservations, which doesn’t change your experience at all. However, it may provide a small amount of commission to help support the running of our site.
-Story and photos by Jimmy McDonough, Real Food Traveler Eco-Friendly Food, Travel & Adventure Editor
Hungry for more? Read about the “wilder” side of Door County.
Please note: Jimmy was hosted for this trip, as is common practice with travel writers. However, as is our policy, laid out in our Disclosures page, we never let that influence our opinions of a destination or the ability to inform our readers.












0 Comments